Mafia Hearts

Ninety Four Sleepless Nights · Chapter 6 of 6

Chapter 6

By My Life Story Editorial · Published · Updated

Three months later, Arthur Kingsley woke at 7:13 on a Sunday morning and stared at the ceiling.

Nothing was wrong.

That was still strange enough to surprise him.

No racing heart.

No sweat-soaked sheets.

No gun beneath his hand.

No guard outside the bedroom.

Sunlight streamed through curtains in the townhouse his mother had once owned.

And someone was stealing his blanket.

Arthur turned.

Clara Vance was asleep beside him.

Half the comforter had migrated around her.

Arthur smiled.

Their relationship had not begun dramatically.

Not after everything else.

Clara had insisted on that.

“No guns. No kidnappings. No secret ledgers,” she told him on their first actual date.

Arthur had taken her to a restaurant.

A normal restaurant.

He had reserved the entire floor.

Clara had walked in, seen thirty empty tables, and turned around.

“This is not normal.”

“There are civilians downstairs.”

“Arthur.”

“I’m trying.”

She made him cancel the private floor.

They ate beside a noisy family celebrating a twelve-year-old’s birthday.

Arthur hated the paper crown the waiter gave him by mistake.

Clara wore it for two hours.

Their second date involved a baseball game.

Their third involved Eli, because Clara’s brother claimed he needed to “evaluate the terrifying criminal boyfriend.”

Arthur informed him that the description was outdated.

Eli replied that “terrifying semi-retired financial-crime-adjacent boyfriend” was too long.

Arthur had threatened to leave.

Clara bought him another hot dog.

He stayed.

The dismantling of the Kingsley criminal network became messy.

Lawyers.

Investigations.

Asset seizures.

Cooperation agreements.

Arthur surrendered records voluntarily.

Some people called him a traitor.

Others called him a coward.

Arthur discovered he cared less than expected.

Several legitimate Kingsley businesses survived.

Construction.

Logistics.

Property management.

A chain of private security companies that had never participated in illegal operations.

He kept those.

He sold others.

A large portion of the money went into restitution funds and community programs in neighborhoods where his organization had profited for years.

Arthur refused to put his name on the buildings.

Clara found out anyway.

“You really hate being caught doing decent things,” she said.

“I have standards.”

“Terrible ones.”

Eli recovered slowly.

His wrist required surgery.

Nightmares came and went.

He moved into an apartment two blocks from Clara, despite insisting he was perfectly capable of living alone.

Clara visited every day.

Arthur pretended not to.

Eli eventually discovered the expensive grocery deliveries were Arthur’s doing.

He said nothing.

Sometimes gratitude did not need public acknowledgment.

Samuel entered federal protection while testifying against Victor Vale and Dominic Rossi.

Dominic cooperated extensively.

Victor refused.

His trial promised to expose nearly two decades of hidden financial corruption.

For Arthur, the strangest consequence was freedom.

His phone rang less.

Nobody stood outside bathroom doors.

Nobody asked permission before sitting at his table.

People disagreed with him openly.

Clara particularly enjoyed that last privilege.

Arthur looked at her sleeping face.

The gray maid uniform was long gone.

He had found it in the old penthouse laundry after the fire damage was repaired.

Two sizes too small.

Deliberately ordered by Dominic.

Arthur had stared at it for a long time.

Then burned it.

Not because Clara needed him to.

Because he hated what it represented.

A room full of men laughing because another human being had been reduced to a target.

Arthur had participated in quieter versions of the same cruelty throughout his life.

He had never joked about Clara.

But he had allowed an organization where Dominic could.

That distinction no longer comforted him.

Clara shifted.

Her eyes opened.

“You’re staring.”

“Yes.”

“Creepy.”

“Good morning.”

“What time?”

“Seven thirteen.”

“Why are you awake?”

“I slept eight hours.”

Clara smiled sleepily.

“Show-off.”

Arthur touched her cheek.

She covered his hand.

“You okay?”

“Yes.”

“You sure?”

“Yes.”

She studied him anyway.

That was Clara.

She never accepted the first answer when a second truth might be hiding underneath it.

Arthur kissed her forehead.

She frowned.

“That’s not where my mouth is.”

His eyebrow lifted.

“Demanding.”

“I spent six months cleaning your house under a fake employment history. I earned demanding.”

“You used your real name.”

“We’ve had this argument.”

He kissed her properly.

For a man once feared throughout Chicago, Arthur had discovered that being wanted by one stubborn woman felt more dangerous than being hated by hundreds of enemies.

Because hatred asked nothing intimate of him.

Love did.

Love required trust.

Apologies.

Honesty.

Patience.

And, occasionally, surrendering half a blanket.

Later that morning, they met Eli for breakfast.

He arrived carrying an envelope.

“I found something.”

Clara groaned.

“No.”

“What?”

“We agreed. No more mysteries before coffee.”

“This one’s good.”

Arthur took the envelope.

Inside was a photograph.

The three of them outside the old townhouse.

Clara recognized it from two weeks earlier.

Someone had taken it during a barbecue.

On the back, Eli had written:

WHEN THE KING FINALLY SLEEPS, LOOK HOME.

Clara laughed.

“You’re impossible.”

“I learned from Dad.”

Their father had died years earlier.

The mention should have hurt.

Instead it felt warm.

Arthur studied the words.

“Look home?”

Eli pointed toward the townhouse.

“I hid something.”

Arthur sighed.

“I’m beginning to dislike your family traditions.”

Clara was already standing.

They searched for twenty minutes.

Eli offered no help.

Arthur checked cabinets.

Clara checked drawers.

Finally she noticed something behind an old photograph of Arthur’s mother.

A small envelope.

Inside was a copy of Eli’s original recorded message.

And a handwritten letter.

For Arthur.

He opened it.

Arthur,

If Clara found you, then either everything went terribly wrong or exactly right.

Probably both.

I don’t know whether I’ll be there when you read this.

But if I’m not, I want you to know why I trusted you.

It wasn’t because you were powerful.

Power is cheap when you’re willing to hurt people.

I trusted you because twice, when nobody knew I was watching, you chose mercy when cruelty would have been easier.

People reveal themselves when they think no one important is looking.

Clara does that too.

She notices.

If she decides there’s something in you worth saving, listen to her.

She’s usually right.

Do not tell her I admitted that.

—Eli

Arthur finished reading.

Clara watched him.

“What does it say?”

“Nothing.”

Eli shouted from the kitchen.

“Liar.”

Clara grabbed for the paper.

Arthur held it above his head.

“That is deeply unfair!”

“You cut open my pillow.”

“Give me the letter!”

“No.”

She chased him around the table.

Eli laughed until he nearly choked.

Arthur eventually surrendered.

Clara read it.

Her expression softened.

“He trusted you before I did.”

“I didn’t deserve it.”

“Maybe not then.”

“And now?”

Clara folded the letter carefully.

“Now you’re improving.”

Arthur pulled her closer.

“Glowing endorsement.”

“Don’t get arrogant.”

He kissed her hair.

Eli groaned.

“I regret surviving.”

Clara threw a napkin at him.

For a while, they simply sat together.

No gunfire.

No encrypted drives.

No dying empire.

Just coffee, pancakes, teasing, and sunlight across an old kitchen table.

Arthur had once believed peace would feel empty.

Instead it felt full.

Weeks later, Clara returned to the penthouse for the first time.

The damaged bedroom had been rebuilt.

Arthur had considered selling the entire place.

Clara asked to see it once.

The bed was new.

The curtains were different.

The ceiling had been repaired.

No trace remained of the feathers scattered across black sheets.

Clara stood in the center of the room.

“You okay?” Arthur asked.

“Yes.”

She looked toward the bed.

“That was where everything changed.”

“You threatened a pillow.”

“I defeated it.”

“You destroyed six thousand dollars in bedding.”

“Dominic said three.”

“He underestimated the sheets.”

Clara laughed.

Then Arthur reached into his jacket.

She narrowed her eyes.

“What are you doing?”

“Nothing alarming.”

“That sentence is alarming.”

He handed her a small velvet box.

Clara stared.

“Arthur.”

“Open it.”

Inside was not a ring.

It was a key.

She looked up.

“What is this?”

“The townhouse.”

“I already have a key.”

“This is different.”

“How?”

“It has your name on the deed now.”

Clara froze.

Arthur continued quickly.

“Half. Not all. I didn’t give you the house. You own half because—”

She shut the box.

“No.”

Arthur stopped.

“No?”

“You cannot transfer half a house to your girlfriend without asking.”

“I thought—”

“I know exactly what you thought.”

Arthur looked genuinely confused.

Clara almost smiled.

“You thought security meant giving me something valuable.”

“Yes.”

“It doesn’t.”

“What does?”

“Knowing that if everything disappears tomorrow, you’re still here.”

Arthur’s expression changed.

She stepped closer.

“I don’t need your house.”

“All right.”

“I don’t need your money.”

“I know.”

“I don’t need your protection every second.”

He looked less convinced.

“Working on it.”

Clara touched his face.

“But I do want you.”

Arthur became completely still.

She smiled.

“That’s the part you keep making complicated.”

“I have limited experience with uncomplicated.”

“Then practice.”

He kissed her.

Behind them, the new pillows remained perfectly intact.

For now.

✦
YOUR CHOICE

Cookie preferences

Read and listen either way. You can change your choice at any time using the link in the footer.

Essential & reading preferences

Remember this choice and the bookmarks, text size and listening settings you choose. Also supports security and publisher sign-in.

Always available

Help us understand story visits, chapter progress and listening using a random browser identifier. No advertising trackers are enabled.

Your choice lasts 180 days on this browser and this website. Read our privacy policy.