Mafia Hearts

The Book on the Fourth Shelf · Chapter 5 of 6

Chapter 5

By My Life Story Editorial · Published · Updated

The safe-deposit box wasn't at Lakeshore National.

That was my father's first trick.

The number my mother had kept for twenty-one years corresponded to an old account, but Daniel discovered the original bank records had been transferred after the merger.

The physical box had been moved to a private storage facility on Wabash.

We arrived just before midnight.

Vanessa came with us.

I hadn't invited her.

Neither had Daniel.

“My father may be involved,” she said when I questioned her. “I'm done letting men decide what I'm allowed to know.”

I couldn't argue with that.

Daniel's security team locked down the building.

Inside the box was a small metal key, three photographs, and a handwritten note from my father.

Seeing his handwriting hurt more than I expected.

I remembered birthday cards.

Lunchbox notes.

Love you, kiddo. Dad.

Now his handwriting belonged to a dead man trying to speak across twenty-one years.

The note read:

Arthur knows where the ledger is. Ellie has the key. Claire is the reason we stop.

I sat down.

Daniel crouched beside me.

“You okay?”

“No.”

He didn't tell me I would be.

I appreciated that.

One photograph showed my father standing beside Arthur Whitmore.

Another showed Richard Vale entering a warehouse.

The third showed Thomas Whitmore shaking hands with Charles Mercer.

Vanessa covered her mouth.

“No.”

On the back was a date.

October 13, 2005.

The night before my father died.

Daniel stared at his own father's face.

I realized something then.

We were both losing our fathers again.

Mine had been a victim.

His might have been a murderer.

Pain didn't care which side you were on.

Daniel stood.

“Arthur knows where the ledger is.”

“Arthur's dead,” Vanessa whispered.

“But he left Claire the letter.”

I pulled it out again.

Ask Daniel about Hawthorne House.

We had.

And Arthur had left the cassette.

Maybe that wasn't all.

“What did Arthur mean by unfinished business?” I asked.

Daniel looked at me.

“He used that phrase constantly near the end.”

“About what?”

“Everything.”

“Anything specific?”

Daniel thought.

Then his eyes changed.

“The hospital.”

“What?”

“He kept asking me to bring him something from Hawthorne House.”

“What?”

“His chessboard.”

I remembered it.

The unfinished game.

We had left it inside.

The fire.

Daniel called his security chief.

“Find out what survived.”

An hour later, we learned the study had been badly damaged, but part of the lower floor remained intact.

The chessboard had been recovered.

By dawn, it sat on Daniel's conference table, blackened around one edge.

I examined it.

Nothing.

Daniel picked up the white king.

It was heavier than it should have been.

He twisted the base.

A tiny brass cylinder dropped out.

Inside was another key.

Vanessa stared.

“Your grandfather was insane.”

Daniel almost smiled.

“He was thorough.”

The key had a number engraved on it.

Daniel recognized it.

“Union Station.”

The lockers at Union Station had changed years ago, but after several phone calls and one very confused manager, Daniel discovered Arthur had rented a private long-term storage compartment through a company.

Inside was a leather-bound ledger.

And a flash drive.

We didn't open either there.

We took them to Daniel's office.

The ledger contained names.

Judges.

Contractors.

Union officials.

Police officers.

Politicians.

Payments stretching across decades.

Richard Vale.

Thomas Whitmore.

Charles Mercer.

But the last entries were recent.

Very recent.

Vale had continued the network.

Arthur had been gathering evidence until weeks before his death.

Daniel stared at the pages.

“This could destroy half the people my family has worked with.”

“Good,” I said.

He looked at me.

I expected an argument.

Instead he nodded.

“Good.”

The flash drive contained scanned documents and audio recordings.

One file was labeled MICHAEL.

My hands shook as I clicked it.

My father's voice filled the room.

“I don't know whether anyone will hear this.”

I stopped breathing.

It had been more than two decades since I'd heard his voice.

Memory does cruel things.

You think you remember someone perfectly.

Then you hear them again and realize you've forgotten the rhythm.

The pauses.

The little breath before a sentence.

I started crying.

Quietly.

Daniel moved beside me but didn't touch me.

My father continued.

“Vale knows I've been copying records. Thomas knows too. Arthur wants me to wait. I don't think we have time.”

He paused.

“If something happens to me, Eleanor, take Claire and go. Don't be brave. Don't prove anything. Just keep our girl safe.”

I covered my face.

Daniel finally placed a hand on my shoulder.

My father spoke again.

“And Claire, if you're old enough to hear this someday, I need you to know something.”

I looked at the speaker.

“You were the best thing I ever did.”

I broke.

There was no cinematic way to cry.

No graceful tear.

I bent forward and sobbed.

Daniel pulled me against him.

I didn't care who he was.

For a few minutes, he was simply another human being holding me while my father spoke from twenty-one years ago.

When the recording ended, nobody said anything.

Then Vanessa's phone rang.

She looked at the screen.

“My father.”

Daniel nodded.

“Answer.”

She put it on speaker.

“Vanessa, where are you?”

“With Daniel.”

Charles Mercer swore.

“Listen to me. You need to leave.”

“Did you know Michael Bennett?”

Silence.

“Vanessa.”

“Did you?”

“Yes.”

“Were you involved in his death?”

“No.”

She closed her eyes.

“Then tell me what happened.”

Mercer's voice became tired.

“Thomas Whitmore ordered Vale to frighten him.”

Daniel's face went hard.

“Frighten him how?” Vanessa asked.

“Force his car off the road. Make him understand.”

My stomach turned.

“But Vale went too far,” Mercer continued. “Michael crashed.”

“Then you covered it up.”

“I was young.”

“You were a prosecutor.”

“I had a family!”

“So did Michael Bennett!”

Vanessa was crying now.

Her father fell silent.

Then he whispered, “Vale has Eleanor.”

We all froze.

“You know where?” Daniel demanded.

Mercer hesitated.

“Dad,” Vanessa said. “If you have ever loved me, tell us.”

A long silence.

Then:

“Old Whitmore freight terminal. South Branch.”

Daniel was already moving.

Mercer shouted through the phone.

“Don't go there! Vale has men. Call the FBI.”

Daniel looked at me.

“He's right.”

“What?”

“We give everything to federal authorities now.”

I nodded.

Daniel made the call through an attorney he trusted outside Chicago.

Copies of the ledger and recordings were transmitted.

Names.

Dates.

Everything.

Then we went after my mother.

The freight terminal sat beside the river.

Federal agents were on their way, but Daniel refused to wait.

“So much for listening to the FBI,” I whispered.

“They're eight minutes out.”

“Eight minutes isn't long.”

“Twelve minutes was enough once.”

I understood.

Arthur.

Daniel had been twelve minutes too late.

He wasn't going to be late again.

We entered through a side door with two security men.

My heart hammered.

Then I heard my mother.

“Claire!”

She was tied to a chair across the warehouse.

Richard Vale stood beside her.

He looked almost disappointed.

“You brought Daniel.”

“Let her go.”

Vale smiled.

“Arthur always did have terrible judgment.”

Daniel stepped forward.

“This ends tonight.”

“No, Daniel. It ended twenty-one years ago. Your grandfather simply lacked the courage to accept it.”

“You murdered Michael Bennett.”

“Thomas ordered intimidation.”

“You killed him.”

Vale shrugged.

“Accidents happen.”

Rage moved through me.

My mother shook her head desperately.

“Claire, don't.”

Vale looked at me.

“Your father had the same expression.”

Daniel moved in front of me.

Vale laughed.

“Oh, this is interesting.”

“Let Eleanor go.”

“And you'll give me the ledger?”

“No.”

Vale's smile disappeared.

Daniel continued.

“The FBI already has it.”

For the first time, Richard Vale looked afraid.

Then one of his men raised a gun.

Everything happened at once.

Daniel pushed me behind a concrete pillar.

A shot cracked through the warehouse.

Security moved.

My mother screamed.

And Daniel went down.

“Daniel!”

Blood spread across his black shirt.

I dropped beside him.

His eyes found mine.

“Get your mother.”

I pressed both hands against the wound.

“I'm a nurse, remember?”

Sirens screamed outside.

Vale ran.

Federal agents flooded the building.

My mother was freed.

But I barely saw any of it.

All I saw was Daniel.

His face had gone pale.

“Stay with me,” I ordered.

He gave me the faintest smile.

“Bossy.”

“You have no idea.”

His eyes began closing.

I slapped his cheek.

“Daniel.”

“Claire—”

“No. Look at me.”

He did.

“You are not allowed to be twelve minutes too late for your own life.”

And as paramedics rushed toward us, I realized the possibility of losing Daniel Whitmore frightened me far more than it should have.

---

✦
YOUR CHOICE

Cookie preferences

Read and listen either way. You can change your choice at any time using the link in the footer.

Essential & reading preferences

Remember this choice and the bookmarks, text size and listening settings you choose. Also supports security and publisher sign-in.

Always available

Help us understand story visits, chapter progress and listening using a random browser identifier. No advertising trackers are enabled.

Your choice lasts 180 days on this browser and this website. Read our privacy policy.