Mafia Hearts

The Cake Nobody Ate · Chapter 3 of 6

Chapter 3

By My Life Story Editorial · Published · Updated

By sunset, Lily and I had moved into the Moretti family wing.

Calling it “moving” was generous.

Two security officers carried our clothes upstairs while I followed them protesting that I was perfectly capable of carrying my own suitcase.

Dominic ignored me.

Lily thought it was an adventure.

“Do we live here now?”

“No.”

“Can we?”

“No.”

“Ethan has a movie room.”

“I know.”

“And popcorn.”

“You have popcorn downstairs.”

“But his machine makes it.”

“You are not moving into someone’s house because of a popcorn machine.”

She considered that.

“What about the swimming pool?”

“Lily.”

She sighed dramatically.

Children were resilient.

Adults were not.

I couldn’t stop thinking about the sedative inside that candy wrapper.

The stranger saying, Stay quiet, sweetheart.

What if Lily had eaten it?

What if she had fallen asleep somewhere nobody found her?

What if Vincent had returned?

Questions kept multiplying.

Answers did not.

Dominic assigned two guards outside our suite.

I hated it.

I also slept slightly better knowing they were there.

The investigation into Vincent Caruso uncovered things nobody expected.

For eleven years, Vincent had managed portions of the Moretti family’s financial empire.

Legitimate companies.

Real estate.

Import businesses.

Private holdings.

He had attended Ethan’s christening.

He had been there when Dominic’s wife, Isabella, died five years earlier after a sudden illness.

He brought Ethan expensive birthday presents.

He ate Christmas dinner at Dominic’s table.

Yet during the previous eighteen months, Vincent had quietly diverted money through shell companies.

Not enough to attract immediate attention.

A few hundred thousand here.

Another transfer there.

Eventually, the total exceeded twelve million dollars.

Dominic discovered the theft only because Gabriel’s team started examining everything Vincent had touched.

But stealing money didn’t explain why he wanted Ethan dead.

That answer began emerging on the third day.

I was helping Lily build a tower from wooden blocks in Ethan’s playroom when shouting erupted downstairs.

Dominic rarely shouted.

I immediately stood.

“Stay here.”

“With Ethan?”

“Yes.”

Ethan looked worried.

“I’ll watch her.”

I hurried downstairs.

Gabriel was in Dominic’s office holding a folder.

Dominic stood behind his desk.

“You knew?”

“No,” Gabriel answered.

“What’s happening?” I asked.

Both men turned.

Dominic hesitated.

“Claire, this doesn’t concern—”

I folded my arms.

“If it concerns the man who tried to drug Lily, it concerns me.”

Dominic gave me a look.

I gave him one back.

Gabriel almost smiled.

Finally, Dominic gestured toward a chair.

Gabriel placed a document in front of me.

It was a corporate ownership chart.

One branch led to a company called Caruso Maritime.

“What am I looking at?”

Dominic answered.

“Vincent believed part of my organization belonged to his family.”

“Did it?”

“Before I took control, yes.”

Years earlier, Dominic’s father and Vincent’s uncle had been business partners.

After a violent dispute, Dominic’s father gained control.

Vincent never accepted it.

When Dominic inherited the operation, Vincent expected a partnership.

Dominic instead transformed many operations into legitimate businesses and refused to share leadership.

“He thought Ethan was the reason I wouldn’t name him successor,” Dominic said.

I stared.

“Successor?”

“If anything happens to me, Ethan inherits my legitimate holdings through trusts.”

“And Vincent?”

“Gets nothing.”

A chill ran along my arms.

“So he wanted Ethan dead because of money?”

“Money. Pride. Power.”

Gabriel added, “And something worse.”

He handed Dominic another document.

A medical record.

Dominic read it.

His face changed.

“What?”

I asked.

Dominic didn’t answer.

“Dominic?”

It was the first time I had called him by his first name at work.

He noticed.

So did I.

But neither of us corrected it.

Gabriel spoke.

“Vincent was the person who recommended Mrs. Moretti’s private nurse during her final illness.”

Dominic went pale beneath his tan complexion.

“No.”

“Dominic—”

“No.”

Gabriel continued carefully.

“We’re reviewing the nurse’s history.”

“What are you saying?”

“The nurse disappeared six weeks after Isabella died.”

I understood before Dominic wanted to.

“You think Vincent…”

“We don’t know.”

Dominic slammed the folder onto the desk.

“Then don’t say it.”

Silence.

I had never seen him lose control like that.

He walked toward the window.

For years, I had known the story only in fragments.

Isabella Moretti had developed a rare autoimmune illness.

Her condition worsened quickly.

She died at thirty-one.

Ethan was three.

Dominic had never remarried.

For all his power, he had been helpless while the woman he loved disappeared.

Now someone was suggesting that helplessness might have been manufactured.

I crossed the room.

I shouldn’t have.

I was his employee.

But I placed one hand lightly on his arm.

He didn’t move.

“If Vincent was involved,” I said, “you’ll find out.”

Dominic looked down at my hand.

Then at me.

“What if I should have found out five years ago?”

“You trusted someone.”

“I don’t trust anyone.”

“You trusted him.”

His expression darkened.

“And look what happened.”

Before I could respond, Lily screamed upstairs.

Dominic moved before I did.

We ran.

He reached the playroom first.

Ethan stood by the window.

Lily was crying.

A small object lay on the floor.

“What happened?” I shouted.

Ethan pointed.

“Something hit the glass.”

There was a spiderweb crack near the window frame.

Gabriel burst in.

“Down!”

He pulled both children away from the window.

Security flooded the room.

I grabbed Lily.

Dominic grabbed Ethan.

Gabriel examined the floor.

A metal pellet.

Not a bullet.

A message.

Attached to it was a folded scrap of paper.

Dominic opened it.

Three words.

SHE SHOULD FORGET.

I felt Lily shaking.

Dominic’s face went cold.

This wasn’t simply about Ethan anymore.

Vincent knew Lily had seen him.

He knew she was talking.

He wanted her silent.

Dominic ordered every curtain closed.

The children were moved to an interior safe room.

Security swept the grounds.

The projectile had been fired from beyond the estate wall.

No shooter remained.

That night, Dominic sat outside the safe room alone.

I found him there at two in the morning.

“You should sleep,” I said.

“So should you.”

“I tried.”

“So did I.”

I sat beside him.

For several minutes we listened to the faint hum of ventilation.

“Is Ethan asleep?”

“Yes.”

“Lily?”

“Across the bed sideways.”

His mouth twitched.

“She kicked Ethan twice.”

“Sounds right.”

Silence returned.

Then Dominic said, “I nearly sent you away six years ago.”

I looked at him.

“What?”

“When you applied for this job.”

“Why?”

“You had a newborn.”

“Lily wasn’t born yet.”

“Pregnant.”

I remembered.

I had been seven months pregnant and desperate for stable work after Lily’s father disappeared before her birth.

“I thought hiring someone in your situation would be complicated,” Dominic admitted.

“That sounds like discrimination.”

“It probably was.”

I laughed quietly.

“What changed your mind?”

“Isabella.”

The name softened his voice.

“She interviewed you after I left.”

“I remember.”

“She told me if I didn’t hire you, she would.”

I smiled.

“I liked her.”

“She liked you.”

He looked toward the safe-room door.

“She would have loved Lily.”

Emotion caught me unexpectedly.

“I wish Lily remembered her.”

“She remembers pictures.”

“Ethan remembers more.”

“Unfortunately.”

I understood.

Losing someone is painful.

Remembering just enough to miss them can be worse.

Dominic leaned forward.

“I keep thinking about that fork.”

“What?”

“One inch from Ethan’s mouth.”

His voice became rough.

“If Lily had been looking somewhere else…”

“But she wasn’t.”

“If she had hesitated…”

“She didn’t.”

“If—”

“Dominic.”

He stopped.

“You can torture yourself with every version of what might have happened.”

I looked toward the door where our children slept.

“Or you can be grateful for what did.”

“Our children.”

The phrase escaped naturally.

His gaze shifted to me.

I realized what I had said.

“My child and your child.”

“I knew what you meant.”

There was something different in the way he looked at me.

Not employer and employee.

Not boss and housekeeper.

Two parents sitting on the floor at two in the morning because someone had threatened their children.

Then his phone buzzed.

The moment disappeared.

Gabriel’s message contained a photograph.

Vincent Caruso entering an abandoned warehouse in Yonkers.

Taken forty minutes earlier.

Dominic stood.

“You found him?”

“Possibly.”

I stood too.

“Don’t go.”

His brows lifted.

“Excuse me?”

“You have people for this.”

“I’m going.”

“Because you want answers or revenge?”

His eyes hardened.

“Both.”

“And if it’s a trap?”

“Then it’s a bad one.”

“You don’t know that.”

“Claire—”

“You have Ethan upstairs.”

He stopped.

“You’re his father before you’re anything else.”

Something shifted in his expression.

I stepped closer.

“Don’t make him lose another parent because you’re angry.”

That landed.

For several seconds, Dominic said nothing.

Then he called Gabriel.

“Send the tactical team.”

Gabriel sounded surprised.

“You’re not coming?”

“No.”

Dominic looked at me.

“I’m staying with my son.”

The warehouse was empty.

Vincent had left minutes before security arrived.

But he left something behind.

A burner phone.

Inside were photographs of the estate.

Schedules.

Security codes.

Pictures of Ethan leaving school.

Pictures of Lily at the grocery store with me.

And one photograph that made Dominic go completely silent.

It showed Isabella Moretti sitting in a hospital room five years earlier.

Beside her stood Vincent Caruso.

On the back, someone had written:

The first heir should have been enough.

Dominic stared at those words for a long time.

Then he said, “This started before Ethan’s birthday.”

Gabriel nodded.

“How long before?”

Dominic looked toward the stairs.

“Maybe five years.”

And suddenly, the cake no longer felt like the beginning of the story.

It felt like the moment an old secret finally failed to stay buried.

✦
YOUR CHOICE

Cookie preferences

Read and listen either way. You can change your choice at any time using the link in the footer.

Essential & reading preferences

Remember this choice and the bookmarks, text size and listening settings you choose. Also supports security and publisher sign-in.

Always available

Help us understand story visits, chapter progress and listening using a random browser identifier. No advertising trackers are enabled.

Your choice lasts 180 days on this browser and this website. Read our privacy policy.