Mafia Hearts

The Woman in the Cathedral Aisle · Chapter 1 of 6

Chapter 1

By My Life Story Editorial · Published · Updated

The cathedral doors opened at exactly four seventeen in the afternoon.

Every man in the front pew reached beneath his jacket.

Every woman turned toward the aisle.

And I stopped breathing.

Bianca Valente was supposed to be standing there.

She wasn't.

Instead, an old woman dressed entirely in black stepped through the enormous wooden doors, clutching a bloodstained envelope against her chest.

For five seconds, nobody moved.

Then she started walking toward me.

Slowly.

Deliberately.

Like she had been waiting five years for this moment.

I stood at the altar beneath hundreds of white roses, wearing a black tuxedo tailored in Milan and a wedding ring I had never wanted in my pocket.

Behind me, Father Luca whispered, "Matteo?"

I didn't answer.

My name is Matteo Bellandi.

For most of my adult life, people had been afraid to keep me waiting.

Politicians returned my calls before I finished leaving messages. Bankers opened offices after midnight. Men who had spent twenty years pretending they feared nothing lowered their voices when they entered my home.

But on the afternoon I was supposed to marry Bianca Valente, none of that power meant anything.

Because the woman walking toward me was Maria Bellini.

And I hadn't seen her since Isabella's funeral.

A murmur moved through the cathedral.

Nearly four hundred guests filled the pews. Half of them were legitimate members of the city's elite. The other half were men whose names appeared in police intelligence files more often than society pages.

Bianca's father, Salvatore Valente, stood in the front row.

His expression changed first from confusion to irritation, then to something much more interesting.

Fear.

I noticed.

So did my younger brother, Luca, standing beside me as my best man.

"Matteo," Luca said quietly. "Something's wrong."

I already knew.

Maria reached the altar.

She looked smaller than I remembered. Five years had bent her shoulders and turned the last traces of brown in her hair silver, but her eyes were unchanged.

Sharp.

Sad.

Unforgiving.

She had taught violin at the Saint Cecilia Conservatory for almost forty years.

More importantly, she had taught Isabella Romano.

The woman I had loved.

The woman I had buried.

"Mrs. Bellini," I said.

Her hands trembled.

"Don't marry her."

The cathedral erupted in whispers.

Salvatore Valente stood.

"Remove this woman."

Two of my security men started forward.

I raised one hand.

They stopped immediately.

Maria looked past me toward Salvatore.

His face had gone pale.

That interested me even more.

"Why?" I asked.

Maria held out the envelope.

There was dried blood across one corner.

"Because your bride knows what you did five years ago."

My jaw tightened.

"What I did?"

"Take it."

I didn't.

Not immediately.

I looked at Luca.

He gave me the smallest shake of his head.

Danger.

Maybe a trap.

Maybe poison.

Maybe explosives.

In our world, paranoia was simply another word for surviving long enough to have gray hair.

Maria understood my hesitation.

"The blood is mine," she said.

She turned her wrist.

A fresh bandage showed beneath her sleeve.

"Someone tried to take it from me this morning."

That changed everything.

I took the envelope.

Inside was a photograph.

For one heartbeat, my mind refused to understand what my eyes were seeing.

Then the entire cathedral disappeared.

The guests.

The flowers.

The candles.

The priest.

Everything.

There was only the photograph.

Isabella.

Her dark hair was longer.

Her face was thinner.

She was standing beside an unfamiliar window wearing a pale gray sweater.

There was a small scar above her eyebrow that hadn't existed five years ago.

But it was her.

I knew the slope of those shoulders.

The tiny crookedness of her left little finger.

The half-moon birthmark near her collarbone.

I knew her because I had spent six years memorizing every part of her.

And five years trying to forget.

"No," I whispered.

Luca looked over my shoulder.

"Jesus."

On the back, written in black ink, were four words.

SHE IS STILL ALIVE.

My fingers went numb.

Five years earlier, Isabella's car had been discovered near the coast after midnight.

Burned.

Destroyed.

The body inside had been almost impossible to identify.

The medical examiner had relied on dental records, jewelry, and personal belongings.

I had identified her mother's necklace myself.

I had stood beside a closed coffin because there had been nothing left for me to see.

I had put white lilies on her grave.

Every Sunday for a year.

Then every month.

Then whenever I could survive standing there.

And now I was holding a photograph of a dead woman who had somehow grown five years older.

"When?" I asked.

Maria understood.

"Three weeks ago."

I looked at her.

"Where?"

"I don't know."

My voice dropped.

"Maria, think very carefully before you answer me again."

She didn't flinch.

"I don't know."

Salvatore moved into the aisle.

"This is absurd. Matteo, we're being humiliated in front of the entire city."

I looked at him.

"Sit down."

His face hardened.

"My daughter is missing."

"And you think I've forgotten?"

"This wedding—"

"Sit. Down."

He did.

Not because I shouted.

I didn't.

Men like Salvatore understood that the quieter I became, the more dangerous the situation was.

I turned back to Maria.

"Who gave you this?"

"A man left it beneath my apartment door yesterday."

"And you waited until now?"

"I tried calling you."

"My private number?"

"No."

"Then you didn't call me."

Her eyes flashed.

"Your people wouldn't let me through."

That was possible.

Hundreds of strangers claimed emergencies every week to get access to me.

"Why come here?"

"Because the note inside told me to."

"There was another note?"

She nodded.

"One sentence."

"What did it say?"

Maria swallowed.

"Give Matteo the photograph when the bride fails to arrive."

A chill moved through me.

Whoever had sent it knew Bianca wouldn't arrive.

Which meant this had been planned.

Before I could speak, every light in the cathedral flickered.

My security detail reacted instantly.

Men moved toward exits.

Luca grabbed my arm.

Then the massive presentation screen near the choir loft came alive.

It had been installed to show photographs from the wedding reception.

Instead, static filled it.

Someone screamed.

The static disappeared.

Bianca appeared.

Her wedding dress was still on.

Her blond hair had fallen loose from its pins.

She was tied to a wooden chair.

Alive.

Terrified.

"Bianca!" Salvatore shouted.

She couldn't hear him.

Or if she could, she gave no sign.

The screen split.

A second room appeared.

A woman sat beneath a single hanging light.

Dark hair.

Gray sweater.

My heart stopped.

Isabella.

Not a photograph.

Not a memory.

Alive.

She lifted her head.

For one impossible second, she looked directly into the camera.

And I saw the woman I had buried.

Older.

Exhausted.

But unmistakably alive.

A distorted voice came through the cathedral speakers.

"Good afternoon, Matteo."

My men searched the balconies.

"Trace it," I told Luca.

He already had his phone out.

The voice continued.

"You have spent your life believing power means having choices."

Isabella's image remained perfectly still.

Bianca struggled against her restraints.

"Today," the voice said, "you get only one."

The screen displayed a digital clock.

07:42:18.

Seven hours.

Forty-two minutes.

Counting down toward midnight.

"One woman gives you an empire. The other destroys it."

Salvatore shouted, "You son of a—"

I grabbed him before he could finish.

"Quiet."

The voice continued.

"Choose before midnight."

The screen went black.

Chaos exploded.

Guests surged toward the doors.

Security teams shouted.

Phones appeared everywhere.

I didn't hear any of it.

I reached into my pocket.

Pulled out the wedding ring.

Placed it on the altar.

Luca stared at me.

"What are you doing?"

"The wedding is over."

Salvatore charged toward me.

"You don't get to decide that!"

I caught his wrist.

"Your daughter is tied to a chair somewhere in this city. Isabella has been held for five years. Somebody walked into our lives, manipulated both families, and just hijacked the security system of a cathedral surrounded by forty armed men."

I released him.

"So yes, Salvatore. At this particular moment, I decide everything."

His nostrils flared.

"If you choose that woman over Bianca—"

"This isn't about choosing either woman."

It hurt to say it.

Because some part of me had already chosen Isabella five years ago.

That was why I had never truly given Bianca my heart.

Our marriage had been an alliance.

Bianca knew that.

I had respected her enough never to lie about it.

But respect wasn't love.

Isabella had been love.

And love had nearly destroyed me.

I turned toward Maria.

"You're coming with us."

She nodded.

Twenty minutes later, the cathedral was locked down.

My security chief, Enzo Ricci, moved guests into controlled groups while our technical team traced the video.

Nothing.

The transmission had bounced through servers across four countries.

Professional.

Prepared.

Luca joined me in the sacristy.

Maria sat across from us.

Salvatore stood near the door, refusing to leave.

"Tell me everything," I said.

Maria folded her hands.

"The night Isabella disappeared, she came to the conservatory."

My pulse changed.

"She told me she was going home."

"She came back."

"What time?"

"Almost eleven."

That had never appeared in the police report.

"Why?"

"She had forgotten her violin."

Maria's voice softened.

"She always forgot something when she was upset."

I remembered.

Keys.

Phone.

Music.

Once, one shoe.

"What happened?"

"I heard voices."

"Whose?"

"Isabella's and a man's."

"Did you see him?"

"No."

"What did he say?"

Maria closed her eyes.

"I remember one sentence."

I waited.

"He said, 'If Matteo chooses love, he'll destroy his own family.'"

The room became very still.

"Anything else?"

"Isabella said, 'You don't know him.'"

Maria opened her eyes.

"Then the man said, 'I know him better than you ever will.'"

Luca shifted beside me.

I looked at him.

His face revealed nothing.

"Why didn't you tell me five years ago?" I asked Maria.

"I did."

"No, you didn't."

"I told one of your men the morning after Isabella disappeared."

"Who?"

She hesitated.

"I don't remember his name."

"Describe him."

"Forties. Dark hair. Scar near his right ear."

Enzo entered the room just in time to hear her.

His face changed.

I saw it.

"Who?" I asked.

Enzo looked at me.

"Carlo Ventresca."

I knew the name.

Everyone did.

Carlo had been my father's closest adviser.

He had also been the man who supervised the search for Isabella.

"He died three years ago," Luca said.

"Heart attack," Enzo added.

Maria shook her head.

"I gave him my statement. He told me he'd personally bring it to Matteo."

I never received it.

The first crack appeared in the foundation of everything I had believed.

Maria reached into her bag.

"There is something else."

She placed a small piece of tarnished metal on the table.

I recognized the engraving immediately.

A silver vine.

Part of Isabella's violin case.

"Where did you get this?"

"It came with the photograph."

Numbers were scratched into the back.

4-12-7.

11-3-9.

2-18-6.

Luca frowned.

"Coordinates?"

"No."

I knew what they were.

Isabella and I had once spent an entire summer arguing about music because she insisted I could learn violin.

I couldn't.

But I had learned her rehearsal system.

Measure.

Page.

Movement.

The numbers weren't coordinates.

They were references.

I pulled out my phone and searched for the sheet music she had practiced obsessively during the year before she vanished.

Maria understood first.

"Tchaikovsky."

I nodded.

We matched the numbers.

Three letters emerged.

D.

O.

C.

Then another sequence scratched near the edge.

K-17.

Enzo stared at me.

"Dock Seventeen."

Maria shook her head.

"No."

"What?"

"The old Saint Cecilia annex."

I remembered.

The conservatory had once operated a rehearsal building near the industrial waterfront.

It had closed years earlier.

"Which dock?"

"Seventeen."

At 6:03 p.m., three SUVs left the cathedral.

I rode in the first with Luca, Enzo, and Maria.

Nobody spoke.

I stared through the window at the city I supposedly controlled.

Five years.

Someone had hidden Isabella for five years.

Someone had intercepted Maria's statement.

Someone had known my security well enough to manipulate my wedding.

And whoever it was had been close enough to know exactly how I would react.

That frightened me more than any enemy ever had.

Because my enemies knew my reputation.

Only my family knew my weaknesses.

We reached the abandoned conservatory twenty-eight minutes later.

The building stood between two warehouses near the water, its windows broken and brick walls stained by decades of salt and rain.

My men entered first.

Clear.

We followed.

Dust covered the hallway.

Old rehearsal rooms lined both sides.

At the end was a steel door.

Locked.

Enzo forced it.

The room beyond was not abandoned.

There was electricity.

A desk.

Photographs.

Hundreds of them.

Isabella walking across a courtyard.

Isabella reading.

Isabella sleeping beside a window.

Isabella crying.

Some photographs were dated only weeks after her supposed death.

Others were recent.

Someone had documented five years of her life.

Maria covered her mouth.

Luca whispered, "My God."

Then I saw the letters.

A wooden box sat beneath the desk.

Inside were dozens of envelopes.

Every one addressed to me.

Matteo Bellandi.

My home.

My office.

Some even had the private mailing address known only to senior members of my organization.

I opened the oldest.

The handwriting nearly broke me.

Matteo,

If this reaches you, please don't come alone.

They told me you believe I'm dead.

I'm not.

I don't know who I can trust.

I read no further.

Couldn't.

I opened another.

Then another.

Five years of letters.

Five years of Isabella begging me to find her.

And someone had kept every one.

Enzo crouched beside the desk.

"Matteo."

He pointed underneath.

A small red light blinked.

Camera.

Active.

Someone was watching us.

I stepped directly in front of it.

"You wanted my attention."

I looked into the lens.

"You have it."

A printer suddenly activated on the desk.

One sheet emerged.

Luca grabbed it.

His face drained of color.

He handed it to me.

There were only seven words.

ASK YOUR BROTHER WHAT HAPPENED FIVE YEARS AGO.

I looked up.

Luca was staring at me.

And for the first time in my life, my brother looked afraid of me.

✦
YOUR CHOICE

Cookie preferences

Read and listen either way. You can change your choice at any time using the link in the footer.

Essential & reading preferences

Remember this choice and the bookmarks, text size and listening settings you choose. Also supports security and publisher sign-in.

Always available

Help us understand story visits, chapter progress and listening using a random browser identifier. No advertising trackers are enabled.

Your choice lasts 180 days on this browser and this website. Read our privacy policy.