Mafia Hearts

The Woman in the Cathedral Aisle · Chapter 4 of 6

Chapter 4

By My Life Story Editorial · Published · Updated

Enzo Ricci had saved my life three times.

Once in a parking garage.

Once on a highway.

Once in my own kitchen when a man I had trusted for ten years came through the service entrance with a gun.

Enzo had been beside me at Isabella's funeral.

He had stood six feet behind me while I lowered flowers onto her coffin.

He had watched me grieve.

Now I was pointing a gun at his chest.

"Start talking."

Enzo didn't reach for his weapon.

"That video is real."

Luca cursed.

"Great beginning."

"But you're misunderstanding what you're seeing."

"Then help me understand."

"Carlo summoned me to the conservatory that night."

"Why?"

"He said your father wanted Isabella relocated."

My finger tightened slightly around the grip.

"Relocated."

"Protected."

"She ended up imprisoned for five years."

"I didn't know that would happen."

"Did you give Carlo authorization?"

"Yes."

Bianca closed her eyes.

I wanted to shoot him.

That would have been easy.

And predictable.

Carlo wanted rage.

So I asked another question.

"What did the authorization actually say?"

Enzo blinked.

"What?"

"The papers. What did they authorize?"

"Temporary Aurelia protection. Seventy-two hours."

"Signed by my father?"

"Yes."

"Did you verify the signature?"

"No."

"Why?"

"Because Carlo was your father's adviser."

There.

Another manipulated man.

Maybe guilty.

Maybe not.

"What happened after?"

"I left. Isabella was angry but unharmed."

"Did she go willingly?"

"Eventually."

"Why?"

"Carlo told her there was a threat against you."

I looked at Isabella's letter.

Carlo understood all of us.

He had manipulated my father with fear for his sons.

My mother with fear for us.

Isabella with fear for me.

Luca with loyalty.

Enzo with authority.

Me with grief.

He didn't control people through force.

He controlled them through the people they loved.

"Why didn't you tell me?"

"Your father ordered silence."

"Everyone keeps using that excuse."

Enzo's face hardened.

"It's not an excuse. You remember Vittorio as your father. The rest of us remember what happened when people disobeyed him."

That was fair.

Painfully fair.

Bianca spoke.

"Carlo still needs Matteo to believe Enzo betrayed him."

We looked at her.

"Why?"

"Because Enzo controls security."

Exactly.

If I killed or removed Enzo, our defenses weakened.

Another trap.

I lowered the gun.

Enzo exhaled.

"You're not forgiven."

"I know."

"But you're useful."

"Story of my life."

Under other circumstances, I might have smiled.

Not tonight.

Bianca changed out of her wedding dress and into clothes one of my men brought from the safe house.

By 9:46, we had assembled every piece of evidence.

Carlo was alive.

He controlled at least part of Aurelia.

He had arranged Isabella's disappearance.

He had forged financial authorizations.

He had manipulated both families.

But we still didn't know where Isabella was.

Or what the "single truth" beneath everything actually was.

Then Bianca remembered something.

"When Carlo questioned me, he kept asking what Isabella told me about the ledger."

"What ledger?"

"I didn't know."

Maria, who had remained quiet, suddenly stood.

"Her music."

We looked at her.

"Isabella hid things inside compositions."

"Codes?"

"Not exactly. She changed notes."

Maria explained that Isabella had developed a private notation system as a teenager.

Different markings represented letters.

The violin piece at her childhood home might contain a message.

We retrieved the sheet music.

Maria studied it.

Twenty minutes.

Thirty.

The clock moved toward eleven.

Finally she began writing letters.

R.

O.

M.

A.

N.

O.

Romano.

Isabella's family name.

Then:

A-C-C-O-U-N-T.

Romano account.

Bianca leaned forward.

"My father once told me the Romanos had money before Isabella's father died."

I knew that.

Isabella had never cared about it.

Her father, Antonio Romano, owned shipping warehouses.

He died when she was nineteen.

Supposedly an accident.

His company collapsed shortly afterward.

"What if it didn't collapse?" Luca asked.

We searched archived records.

There it was.

A trust created by Antonio Romano.

Worth nearly eighty million dollars at the time.

Current estimated value?

Over two hundred million.

Beneficiary:

Isabella Romano.

But the trust had been frozen after her death.

Control reverted temporarily to trustees.

One trustee.

Carlo Ventresca.

Now I understood.

This had never begun with me.

It began with Isabella's father.

Carlo killed Antonio—or arranged his death—then positioned himself over the trust.

But Isabella remained the beneficiary.

He couldn't access the principal while she lived openly.

If she died, the trust passed to a charitable foundation.

If she disappeared but remained legally dead, Carlo could manipulate the assets indefinitely.

"That's why he kept her alive," Bianca said.

"And why he needed everyone to believe she was dead," Luca added.

But why reveal her now?

Because Bianca had discovered the payments.

The secret was unraveling.

Carlo had decided to destroy the evidence and take both empires while doing it.

The final piece came from my mother.

"Vittorio knew."

I looked at her.

"Knew what?"

"About Antonio Romano."

"That Carlo killed him?"

"Not at first. He suspected it years later."

"Why didn't he expose Carlo?"

"Because Antonio had left evidence with Vittorio."

"What evidence?"

"A ledger."

The ledger.

"Where?"

"I don't know."

My mother looked at me.

"But your father told me something before he died. He said, 'If Matteo ever learns the truth, tell him the house was built before the empire.'"

The house.

Our original family home.

Not the mansion where we lived later.

The small brick house where Luca and I were born.

It still belonged to us.

Nobody had lived there in fifteen years.

11:02 p.m.

We had fifty-eight minutes.

We drove there.

I went straight to my father's old study.

The room had been preserved.

Desk.

Books.

Photographs.

"The house was built before the empire."

I looked at the walls.

Then the floor.

My father had renovated almost everything after he became wealthy.

Except the fireplace.

Original brick.

I searched it.

One brick moved.

Behind it was a steel box.

Inside was a ledger.

Antonio Romano's handwriting filled half.

Vittorio's filled the rest.

Names.

Payments.

Dates.

Bribes.

Murders.

Carlo's network.

Judges.

Police officers.

Businessmen.

Politicians.

Enough evidence to destroy him.

And at the back, one signed confession.

Vittorio Bellandi.

My father admitted that he discovered Carlo's role in Antonio's death too late.

He also admitted something worse.

Carlo had threatened to expose crimes that would destroy both families.

Vittorio agreed to silence.

Then Isabella fell in love with me.

Carlo realized a marriage between us would eventually give Isabella access to the truth about her father's trust.

So he had to separate us.

The argument Isabella overheard five years ago had not been about my leaving the family.

It was about the ledger.

She had discovered part of it.

Carlo abducted her before she could tell me.

My father discovered the truth weeks later.

But by then Carlo threatened to kill Isabella if Vittorio acted.

Dad spent his final year trying to find her.

He failed.

I closed the ledger.

For the first time that night, I understood my father.

Not forgave.

Understood.

My phone rang.

Unknown.

I answered.

Carlo's voice.

No distortion this time.

"Hello, Matteo."

"Carlo."

A soft laugh.

"You finally learned patience."

"Isabella."

"Alive."

"Where?"

"Close."

"If you've hurt her—"

"There he is. The old Matteo."

I stopped.

Carlo laughed again.

"You want to threaten me. That's comforting."

"What do you want?"

"The ledger."

"That's all?"

"And control of the Bellandi and Valente ports."

"You think I'm signing over an empire?"

"I think you'll do almost anything for Isabella."

Almost.

He was right.

"Where?"

"The cathedral."

Of course.

"Midnight."

"Isabella comes first."

"No."

"Then we're done."

I hung up.

Everyone stared at me.

Luca said, "What the hell?"

"He needs the ledger."

"Obviously."

"So we give it to him."

Bianca frowned.

"You're serious?"

"A copy."

Enzo smiled slightly.

"Now you're thinking."

We scanned every page.

The original went into a leather case.

The digital copies were uploaded to secure servers with timed release instructions.

If I didn't cancel by 12:15, the entire ledger would go simultaneously to federal prosecutors, journalists, and every rival Carlo had ever betrayed.

Carlo thought the ledger was power.

It was.

But information only had power while someone could control who saw it.

I intended to make control impossible.

At 11:38, we returned to the cathedral.

The wedding flowers remained.

White roses.

Candles.

Empty pews.

It looked like a beautiful place after everyone had died.

I walked down the aisle alone carrying the case.

"Carlo!"

My voice echoed.

Nothing.

Then the screen came alive.

Isabella appeared.

This time she was inside the cathedral.

I recognized the stone wall behind her.

The crypt.

Beneath us.

Carlo stepped into frame.

Older than I remembered.

Gray-haired.

Smiling.

"Welcome back."

"Let her go."

"Bring the ledger downstairs."

I walked toward the crypt entrance.

Enzo's voice came through the tiny receiver in my ear.

"We're in position."

I descended.

One corridor.

Then another.

Carlo waited inside the old burial chamber.

Isabella sat beside him.

No ropes.

No chains.

But Carlo held a gun.

When she saw me, her face changed.

Five years disappeared from mine.

"Matteo."

I couldn't answer.

Not yet.

Carlo extended his hand.

"Ledger."

I held up the case.

"First tell me why."

He smiled.

"You know why."

"Money?"

"Freedom."

"You imprisoned a woman for five years for freedom?"

"Don't become sentimental."

I looked at Isabella.

She was crying silently.

"Did he hurt you?"

"Not the way you think."

Carlo frowned.

"Enough."

I looked back at him.

"You made one mistake."

"Did I?"

"You thought I would come here angry."

"You are angry."

"Yes."

"But?"

"I asked questions first."

His smile disappeared.

I continued.

"I found the Romano trust."

Nothing.

"My father's confession."

His jaw tightened.

"And copies of the ledger are scheduled for release."

Now fear appeared.

Small.

But real.

"If I don't cancel the transmission by 12:15, everyone gets it."

Carlo raised the gun.

"You bluff badly."

"Do I?"

He studied me.

Then Isabella suddenly said, "He's not bluffing."

Carlo turned toward her.

That second was enough.

I moved.

The gun fired.

Stone exploded beside my head.

Isabella dropped.

I hit Carlo.

We crashed against the crypt wall.

The gun slid across the floor.

Carlo punched me.

I hit him harder.

Five years of grief sat behind that punch.

But I didn't kill him.

That was important.

I held him against the stone.

"You wanted rage."

He spat blood.

"Do it."

"No."

I heard footsteps.

Enzo and my men entered.

Carlo laughed weakly.

"You think this ends with me?"

I looked at him.

"It ends with the truth."

Then Isabella screamed.

"Matteo!"

I turned.

A second gunman emerged from behind a stone column.

He aimed at me.

Before he could fire, Bianca stepped from the opposite corridor and slammed a heavy candle stand into his arm.

The shot went into the ceiling.

Enzo tackled him.

Silence returned.

Bianca stared at the fallen man.

"That," she said breathlessly, "was for ruining my wedding dress."

Despite everything, Isabella laughed.

It was small.

Broken.

Beautiful.

And it was the first sound in five years that made me believe I might actually survive what came next.

✦
YOUR CHOICE

Cookie preferences

Read and listen either way. You can change your choice at any time using the link in the footer.

Essential & reading preferences

Remember this choice and the bookmarks, text size and listening settings you choose. Also supports security and publisher sign-in.

Always available

Help us understand story visits, chapter progress and listening using a random browser identifier. No advertising trackers are enabled.

Your choice lasts 180 days on this browser and this website. Read our privacy policy.